CASE STUDY
Lola Getts
Bringing marketing in-house after 2 years of agency underperformance, and rebuilding paid, lifecycle, and retention from the ground up.
- Industry
- DTC plus-size women's activewear
- Role
- Director of Marketing
- Engagement
- In-house transition executed over 6 months
- Channels
- Meta Ads, Google Ads, Klaviyo, Shopify, Yotpo
THE CHALLENGE
What wasn’t working
Lola Getts had spent about 2 years working with an outside agency to manage its Meta and Google Search campaigns, at a combined cost of $50,000 per month. Over time, the relationship became increasingly frustrating. The agency’s attention felt spread too thin, the creative and copy lacked a real understanding of the brand and its niche, frequent account manager changes led to inconsistent reporting, and conversions continued to underperform.
The breaking point came after the account was handed off to yet another manager, resulting in an oversight in the campaign review process. A weekend promotion went live on Meta with the wrong date in the UTM parameters, causing GA4 to split traffic and conversion data and compromise reporting for the promotion.
While the UTM error was the immediate issue, the bigger problem was a lack of accountability. With repeated management changes, inconsistent quality checks, and no clear ownership of campaign execution, it became clear that the agency wasn't taking the level of responsibility needed to manage the account effectively.
The approach
What I built
I brought marketing fully in-house and rebuilt it around first-party data, real customer language, and a QA process that made reporting trustworthy again.
Tracking and audiences
Fixed Meta Pixel tracking and built lookalike audiences from first-party customer data.
Customer-led pages and copy
Fully customized product and landing pages, and rewrote ad copy using pain points surfaced directly from live show production.
Live show video ads
Incorporated live shopping show clips into video ad creative, which outperformed the prior studio-produced ads.
Klaviyo funnels
Retooled abandoned cart and retention funnels in Klaviyo.
Pre-launch QA
Built a pre-launch QA process for links, UTMs, and promo codes so a reporting failure like the one that triggered this transition couldn't happen again.
Reviews and loyalty
Built a Yotpo reviews and loyalty program from the ground up.
The results
By the numbers
Within 6 months of bringing the account in-house:
- 6-15%+Average Meta CTRAcross Meta campaigns
- 6xBlended ROASAcross paid channels
- $0Agency retainerEliminated entirely
Why it matters
This is what happens when paid media, lifecycle marketing, and live commerce are all managed by one person who has a clear view of the entire customer journey, rather than being spread across multiple vendors. The solution wasn't to spend more money. It was to have better oversight, more reliable data, and creative that reflected what customers were actually saying and responding to.
Want one strategist who owns the whole customer journey?
Prefer to chat first? You can also book a complimentary introductory call using the button in the bottom-right corner of your screen. I look forward to connecting!